Articles Posted in Elder Law

Elder care advocates are understandably up in arms following reports about questionable evictions from a Brooklyn facility catering to seniors. The sad situation is a reminder of the continuing struggles faced by so many local families in their quest for quality, reliable long-term care and support. It is also a troublesome sign that most communities remain drastically unprepared to provide the aid that will be needed in coming decades as the New York population ages.

NY Nursing Residents Evicted After Facility Closure

As reported by the NY Daily News last month, a group of over 100 Brooklyn seniors are currently scrambling to find alternative living arrangements following the announcement of the sudden closure of the Prospect Park Residence. The Park Slope facility has been a home for senior for over 15 years. But that will end in May, as the facility is slated to shut its door by the beginning of June.

The face of New York nursing home care has been changing in recent years. The traditional model of individual counties throughout the state owning and operating facilities to provide care to ailing seniors is being phased out in may places. Instead, the counties are selling the homes to private companies to operate. The moves are spurred in almost all cases by financial realities–the facilities are too expensive for the county to operate.

Understandably, elder advocates worry about the effect of the change on senior care. In the past, some analyses have suggested that privately-run nursing homes, on average, show more “deficiencies” than their public counterparts. The assumption is that private homes are motivated by profit and more willing to cut resources to residents and refuse to pay wages for the best caregivers in order to boost their bottom line.

But is is important to remember that no two homes are identical, and “averages” do not mean that all privately run homes are rampant with neglect and need to be avoided. Early reports out of Ulster County, for example, offer a hopeful reminder that quality decreases may not automatically follow private nursing homes sales.

Nursing home horror stories abound, and everyone has likely heard some tale of seniors suffering neglect at a New York long-term care facility. It is for that reason that elder care advocates always suggest doing your homework before making a final decision about where to receive skilled nursing care.

One of the most well-regarding nursing home ranking system is the federal “Nursing Home Compare” website. The site lists most nursing homes and gives them a star rating, from one to five. The rating is based on health inspections, staffing levels, and various quality measures. As a general guide, browsing the rankings of all local New York homes is a very helpful way to get an idea of home performance.

However, can the star system be relied upon exclusively? Is admission to a home with four or five stars a guarantee that the care provided will be proper?

Messages about elder care, selecting a nursing home, securing Medicaid support, and similar matters are often directed not at the seniors themselves but their adult children. This is a cultural adaptation that recognizes the role that adult children play in caregiving for their parents. While the rate of child-caregivers may be decreasing from decades past, they remain a key component of senior aid throughout New York.

But that begs the question: What about seniors without children?

Planning Need Even More Imperative

New York State has the largest Medicaid system in the country. As most know, Medicaid is a joint state-federal program that provides healthcare to low-income residents. Unlike Medicare (which is a program exclusively for seniors based on their age), Medicaid is for all those who do not have enough assets to pay for the insurance they need out-of-pocket.

Medicaid provides general health care to residents of all ages. In addition it acts as the primary public provider of support for seniors in need of a nursing home stays or other elder care. Considering that each kind of support comes from the same pool of Medicaid money, it is useful for those reliant on the Medicaid system to keep up with all matters that affect the overall budget. In other words, any NY Medicaid budget issues may eventually affect elder care and support options.

Federal Government Adjustment

Any family who has gone through the process of helping a loved one into a New York nursing home understands the initial “sticker shock.” New York remains one of the most expensive states in the country for long-term care.

As outlined in the latest Genworth Cost of Care study (from 2013), the median cost of a private room in a long-term care facility in the state is $125,732 per year. Not only that, but the rate is expected to jump by five percent over the next few years. Notably, the average cost nationwide is only $83,950. This means that our state is near the very top of the list when it comes to caregiving costs for seniors.

Do not forget, however, that these studies only report on averages or the median rate. In certain locations, the costs can even run higher. For example, last week Newsday published a story which found that within New York, Nassau and Suffolk counties average the highest in the state. In those counties, the average stay costs over $145,000 per year.

The combined pressures of growing need, rising costs, and altered ideas of the best way to live one’s golden years is leading to a revolution in the look and feel of elder care. To be sure, changes in the way seniors in need receive support are still occurring far too slow for some advocates. But it is undeniable that many seniors now are cared for differently than their parents and the trend will only continue in the coming years and decades.

One common suggestion is that communal living spaces (like nursing homes) are closing and being replaced by a growth in at-home caregivers. While that change is occurring, it oversimplifies the new landscape of seniors care. There are different version of at-home support and even communal living.

Senior Villages

The future of providing necessary care and support for New York seniors is a hotly debated topic. The analysis is taking place everywhere, including at the local level. As frequently discussed, one of the primary battlegrounds is that of county-run nursing homes. Long a bastion of care for residents, these facilities are being shuttered by some and transferred to private owners.

But not all New York communities are giving up on the idea of publicly-owned long-term care facilities. One area taking a cautious approach is Genesee County which recently commissioned a committee to study various aspects of long-term care in the community to determine the best course of action with regard to the current county nursing home.

NY Elder Care – A Closer Look

While the Affordable Care Act attempted to “bend the cost curve”, the cost of long-term care remains high and is projected to skyrocket in the future. In Illinois, the median annual cost for a nursing home with a private room was $125,732. (Genworth Financial, Inc., survey). Figuring out how to prepare for your long-term care as well as how to pay for it are major life decisions. It is important to take the time to consider your options, discuss your thoughts with your loved ones, and take affirmative steps to put your plan into place without breaking the bank.

Insurance Options

Two of types of health insurance that many have enrolled in, Medicare or traditional health insurance, do not cover long-term care. Medicare and traditional health insurance provide only short-term solutions. Medicare and private health insurance will cover only skilled care that is medically necessary and relates to a recent hospitalization. Notably, disability insurance does not cover long-term care and often many policies end when you turn 65 since disability insurance is only to replace lost wages, not pay for healthcare costs.

A somewhat bizarre story out of Europe is leading a few elder care experts in the United States to question whether “shipping away” seniors may be part of the future of long-term care for some families.

As reported by the BBC, one adult daughter in Switzerland ignited an ethical debate recently by deciding to send her mother to a long-term care home in Thailand for support. The daughter explained that her decision was based on both her mother’s specific condition and financial realities. The 91-year old mother apparently suffers from severe dementia, and is unable to remember much of anything about the present. In addition, the cost of care in Switzerland was incredibly high–similar to that in New York–while Thai care was far more affordable. The daughter felt that her mother could receive better services in Thailand where she now lives with a group of other Swiss and German seniors.

A Wave of the Future?

Contact Information